“Never, never, never, never, never! Pray you, undo this button.”…Shakespeare
Buttons, are one of those few things, that I think can either make or break an outfit. I am not saying that a horribly designed or badly made outfit can be fixed by good buttons, but a wonderful outfit can be ruined by the wrong set. I have also had a few cases, where I went beyond the call of duty to have really cool closures that due to time & wear have ceased to be closing properly, have fallen off or have unraveled. This leads to a very cool outfit sitting in the closet due to said ruined button.
As for buttons themselves you have many options to choose from: Pewter, fabric, leather, hidden, displayed, bought, made, and so on and so forth. Just as there are numerous closure options there are thousands of placed to purchase said closures. Everyone has their favorites, and I would like to share mine.
For Frogs and some basic buttons, I enjoy shopping at
Buttons4U. I would recommend shopping there if you need to buy frogs and some buttons in bulk.
For sca themed buttons, I have had great luck with
Pomegranate Costume Supply. I know some people are not a fan of ordering through ebay, but I have found this seller to be honest, quick (much quicker then traditional stores), and easy to communicate with. An additional thing I really like about them, is that they cleary tell you if you are getting a metal or plastic button...This is mucho important. All the buttons for the upcoming projects are from Pomegranate.
Jo-anns isn’t bad for some buttons, but only if they are 40%-50% off. Otherwise, it is just too expensive.
I haven’t quite learned the finer art of fabric buttons, I will conquer this, and when I do, I will share.
If given the option I would have all my buttons be custom pewter. I don't have the knowledge, the time, or the location to start pewter casting, but I will one day (insert evil grin here). I do have a friend who does the most amazing pewter work (that would be Daphne) and she has been kind enough to do me some favors in the past and created awesome buttons. If you have someone who does pewter casting...make them your friend, or try to learn from them.
When ordering buttons ANYWHERE! Please, Please, PLEASE make sure you are ordering the right size. Some outfits (especially those made from heavy wool) will look silly with small buttons and some linen and silk garments look ridicules with big buttons. For a given male's outfit I recommend at least 30-40 buttons, and for long female cotehardies I say order 70 buttons. You might have some left over, but you can always make favors with them, or use them on sleeves. I would always rather have too many buttons then not enough
If you have favor button supplies, feel free to share :-)